WHY DID THE ASSAULT BRIGADE 2506 GIVE ITS FLAG TO PRESIDENT KENNEDY FOR SAFEKEEPING? 



By: ERNEIDO A. OLIVA
Maj. Gen. (DCNG-Ret.)
Former Second in Command of the Bay of Pigs Invasion
CAMCO Chairman

     Since returning from Cuban prisons after the Bay of Pigs invasion on April 17, 1961 I have been asked hundreds of times why the flag of the Assault Brigade 2506 was presented to President John F. Kennedy on December 29, 1962 at the Orange Bowl in Miami. To many, who are not aware of all the facts, it seems like a paradoxical action since to this day Kennedy is often directly blamed for our defeat in the Bay of Pigs and as a result for Fidel CastroÍs five decades of dictatorship and for all of CubaÍs ongoing troubles.  This perception is a result of the decisions he made to deny the BrigadeÍs freedom fighters the promised air support. There are those who believe that the Brigade was duped into engaging in the flag presenting ceremony by apologies or flattery. However, I thought then, as I do now, that the presentation of the Brigade flag to the President at that time was fully justified and that it was the correct and patriotic thing to do. Until this time I have addressed this topic only with an old friend of the numerous reporters that have come knocking on my door because of the classified information that was involved. Well, the information is now declassified and I would like to put our actions into perspective.

     On December 22, 1962, the majority of the members of the Brigade were allowed to leave Cuba because the United States government had paid the ransom demanded by Castro for our freedom. Before we left CubaÍs San Antonio Air Force Base that day, Castro took the time to visit privately with the BrigadeÍs three leaders:  Dr. Manuel Artime, José Pérez San Roman and I. His goodbye included not only another admonishment for what we had done„something we had heard multiple times during our captivity„but also a personal assurance that if we ever dared return to the island we would be shot on the spot. Our departure was actually delayed by eight hours until the last 1.5 million dollars in cash paid for the three leaders had been deposited in Fidel CastroÍs personal bank account.
 
    When we finally landed at Homestead Air Force Base in Florida, I had barely placed a foot on free soil when an American came running toward me saying that someone on a base phone wanted to talk with me immediately. I was wondering who would be so anxious to speak to me because my wife, Graciela, was still in Cuba with my young daughter. When I answered the phone, Robert Kennedy, the PresidentÍs brother and Attorney General, was on the other end of the line. He warmly welcomed me to the United States and said that in the following days we would be talking about topics of great importance to both of us.

     When Artime, San Roman and I met with Robert Kennedy two days later in Washington, D.C., he told us of paramilitary operations being conducted to overthrow the Castro regime.  His presentation made us quickly forget about the dictatorÍs farewell threat and prompted us to start working on another opportunity to fight for the liberation of our native land.  Kennedy mentioned to us that although plans for the operation that we later learned was called ñOperation Mongoose," were already being implemented, he wanted to make sure that we were included in the process. Operation Mongoose had been approved by President Kennedy in November 1961, only six months after the Bay of Pigs invasion. The recently declassified ñGuidelines for Operation Mongoose" established two very important points: ñ(a) in undertaking the overthrow of the Castro government, the U.S. will make maximum use of indigenous resources, internal and external, but recognizes that final success will require decisive U.S. military intervention. (b) Such indigenous resources as are developed will be used to prepare for and justify this intervention, and thereafter to facilitate and support it."

    In the days after our meeting with Robert Kennedy, the three Brigade leaders spent long hours in Washington and Miami discussing the plans presented to us. We finally unanimously concluded that for the sake of our homeland we had to forget our bitter disappointments with President Kennedy and the lack of promised air support and we needed to accept the new opportunity that was being offered to us. Although we also wanted to ensure that the whole Brigade could participate in the operations. We also agreed to follow the counsel of one of our new American advisors and not yet share the information with any one, not even with our closest friends in the Brigade.

    To show the President that we had made a firm decision to cooperate, as well as to show him our eagerness to fight again for CubaÍs liberation, Artime suggested that we publicly present President Kennedy with our Brigade flag as a symbolic gesture. We decided that I would make the presentation at the conclusion of San RomanÍs brief salutation remarks. When we informed the Attorney General of our decision, White House officials immediately began preparing for what culminated in an extraordinary ceremony in the Orange Bowl that was attended by thousands of Cuban exiles.
It was there that I presented the Brigade flag to President Kennedy and said: "Mr. President, the men of the Brigade 2506 give you their banner; we temporarily deposit it with you for safekeeping." The President then unfolded the flag, paused a few seconds, and in a voice filled with emotion declared:  ñCommander, I can assure you that this flag will be returned to this Brigade in a free Havana." 

    During the weeks that followed, we received information from numerous individuals in the government and most importantly, directly from Robert Kennedy, indicating that Operation Mongoose had failed to do the job and it had been replaced for a new covert effort against Castro. We received assurances that the new effort had the highest priority and that the Administration was committed to the liberation of Cuba. We also learned that hundreds of people were already involved and that dozens of psychological and paramilitary operations had been conducted against the Havana regime. We felt that this time, victory, would be the outcome. 

    In January 1963, Artime and I met Robert Kennedy at his McLeanÍs residence. He commented that we looked strong, energetic and fully recovered from our tough time in prison and told us that the hour had arrived for us to join the U.S. operations against Cuba. Artime would be given enough money to begin paramilitary and psychological
operations from another country, he said, and I would be allowed to train and organize the necessary conventional forces within the U.S. Armed Forces to achieve the goal set by the President. Two months later, Artime departed for Nicaragua with hundreds of men. I went to Fort Benning, Georgia with 207 Brigade members commissioned as U.S. army, air force and navy officers. 500 additional Brigade members went to Fort Jackson, Georgia, where they joined the thousands of Cuban volunteers who had already enlisted in the U.S. Army during the missile crisis of the previous October.

    The President announced the acceptance of the Brigade members into the U.S. armed forces in a JanuaryÍs press conference and named me as the representative of all Cuban-Americans enlisted in the U.S. Armed Forces. All these incredibly fast moving events happened following what was a widely held belief„that the President of the United States and the Prime Minister of the Soviet Union had made a firm commitment to not invade Cuba after the missile crisis. Through the years many have vehemently held to this belief. Academicians, reporters, historians and some Cuban-Americans have blamed John F. Kennedy for stopping all actions against Castro after the failed Bay of Pigs invasion. I can tell you first hand that he did not.

    Along with the rest of the country, the assassination of the President on November 22, 1963 came as a tremendous shock to me. I was at Fort Sill, Oklahoma working with another Cuban officer assigned to that military base on a plan to organize a Cuban infantry brigade within the U.S. Army when I heard the news. Our Brigade officers had been already dispersed to different U.S. I didnÍt realize at first but as a result of the loss of President Kennedy our plans, efforts and dreams for a free Cuba were about to be ended. On January 14, 1964, it was new President Lyndon B. Johnson who at the White House and in front of Robert Kennedy advised me of his decision to stop all activities against Cuba. I then had to relate the devastating news to all Cuban exile personnel wearing an American military uniform. Castro has certainly profited from that criminal act in Dallas.

    Alexander M. Haig, Army General and former Secretary of State, made the first public reference to my participation in ñOperation Mongoose" in his book entitled ñInner Circles."  During the time of the operation Haig was a lieutenant colonel and special assistant to the Secretary of the Army, Cyrus Vance, who was closely coordinating the PentagonÍs Cuban operations with me. In his book Haig wrote: This was an extraordinary statement (President KennedyÍs words at the Orange Bowl) coming from the man who had left the Brigade to its fate when he alone had the power to save it. No doubt he meant what he said at the momentƒOperation Mongoose was authorized by President Kennedy in the wake of the Bay of Pigs ƒmany in the Orange Bowl that night must have been aware of its existence." The American people knew nothing about itƒThirteen raids into Cubaƒwere approved for the three-month period beginning in November 1963, the last month of the Kennedy presidency. With the authorization of Vance and the advice of Erneido Oliva, among others, I processed the decisions, handing them on to representatives of the CIA for execution by their operatives in the field."

    I hope that members of the Brigade and the general public realize that the fault for forty-six years of dictatorship in Cuba should not fall solely on the shoulders of John F. Kennedy. It is a fact that our defeat at the Cuban beaches consolidated the Castro regime. But it also needs to be realized that President Kennedy wanted to continue the fight to remove the tyrant from power. The President who failed us at the Bay of Pigs was truly and sincerely remorseful about his failure to support us and he worked to rectify his historic mistake and to free Cuba of the tyrantÍs communist dictatorship.

    Throughout the years I have continued doing whatever was in my power to convince key personnel in the six Administrations that followed President JohnsonÍs to do something to liberate the Cuban people. As I have often said, no one was willing to move a finger against the tyrant. However, attitudes regarding Cuba have changed dramatically in the last two years. We now have a U.S. President who has shown determination and courage in liberating countries far from our shores. A president who says that he places this nation on the side of the world's oppressed people. ''All who live in tyranny and hopelessness can know: The United States will not ignore your oppression or excuse your oppressors. When you stand for your liberty, we will stand with youƒOur country has accepted obligations that are difficult to fulfill and would be dishonorable to abandon."

     The Cuban dictator, only 90 miles from our shores, has made an increasing number of mistakes which have brought him isolation from even his former European allies. He is not getting younger but more tyrannical by the day. As Chairman of the Cuban American Military Council (CAMCO), I have spoken with many Cubans who have recently arrived to the United States. These new arrivals emphasize the deteriorating social and economic situation in Cuba. They talk about the gossip among CastroÍs cronies on what is going to happen to them after the tyrant disappears from the picture or how they will be able to survive an unavoidable transition to democracy. They also describe how the aging dictator is becoming more fragile, senile and eccentric. They bitterly show pictures of the two Cubas. The Cuba showing the happy faces of tourists who touch down briefly to sample the white sandy beaches, luxury hotels and warm Caribbean sun and the Cuba showing the faces of  95% of the population„the poor, the disenfranchised, the captive, living in dilapidated homes and scrounging for food, water, fuel and other necessities of life.

     I believe that after forty-six years of Castro dictatorship the time is nearing when Cuba will be free. It may be that in the not too distant future former Assault Brigade 2506 members and their families and the entire Cuban community will assemble again. This time the place will not be the Orange Bowl in Miami but it will be in a free Havana, in a place that will have changed its name from ñRevolution Square" to ñLiberty Square." And at that place I hope to hear another President of the United States say, ñMembers of the Assault Brigade 2506, I am here in a Free Cuba, returning to you the flag that was given to us for safekeeping in December 1962."

 

WWW.CAMCOCUBA.ORG
CAMCOCUBA@AOL.COM